Strength Training Edges Out Other Activities on Depression
Graded Strong — an analysis pooling 80 trials with over 6,000 people, each assigning groups by chance; results varied a lot between trials.
- Design
- Meta-analysis
- Participants
- 6,123
- Duration
- —
- Funding
- —
Strength training eased depression symptoms slightly more than aerobic exercise, relaxation or stretching did.
Strength training was already known to ease symptoms of depression compared with doing nothing. The open question was how it stacks up against other activities thought to lift mood, such as aerobic exercise, relaxation, stretching or mind-body exercise. Against these, too, strength training came out slightly ahead. The edge was small, but it showed up clearly.
Researchers pooled 80 trials with a total of 6,123 people. In each trial, chance decided who did at least three weeks of training with weights or resistance. The others did a different activity or got no extra treatment. Participants were 57 years old on average, and two thirds were women. The advantage was largest in people with a mental illness. Compared with no treatment at all, the effect was moderate in size.
Results varied a lot from trial to trial. Trials that kept group assignment better hidden in advance found smaller effects. Whether strength training could replace existing depression treatment was not tested. The authors still see their results as support for recommending strength training in depression.
Disclaimer: Research summaries are provided for informational purposes only and do not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional before making changes to your health routine.
